So Much for a New World Order

Well, it didn’t take too long on the fifth day for the South Africans to bundle the No. 1 ranking and give it back to Australia. The defeat was particularly ironic in that South Africa made the largest innings score in the match, ranking among some of the highest 4th innings scores in history. If they had only made a similar score the first time around, maybe they would have had a chance of saving the match.

Kudos to Australia from coming back from demoralizing Test and one-day series losses to SA at home, and then beating them in their own den with a bunch of debutants who performed brilliantly. This puts the previous South African win in a different light now. Maybe they were just lucky in the first two Tests in Australia. But the defeats helped Australia regroup and reclaim what is definitely theirs. They deserve it.

We, on this blog, have been guilty, like many others, of gloating at Australia’s recent troubles. But I would justify it as hoping for a more level playing ground for teams and greater competitiveness on the world stage. Think of how boring the 2003 and 2007 World Cups were. This is not just about Australia. There is nothing more nauseating than watching two mismatched teams play, which pretty much defines any match played by Australia in the last few years. This post by Philip Oliver misses that point.

For SA, maybe they can try to regain some pride by winning the last match. They still have a lot of work to do in the coming years to prepare for the next encounter with the Aussies. I would say that this series defeat would rankle more than the previous 3-0 whitewashes. Rarely have we seen the crown snatched so cruelly and so quickly from a new monarch.

Overall Series Results Success %age

So let us look at the consolidated success %age (both home and away series). Despite their recent losses, Australia are at the top of the table by virtue of having 2 more wins against draws by SA. India seems a strong team and their recent 2-0 victory against Australia lead to claims that they are No. 1. According to this chart, they have some ways to go. More to the point, their high ranking obscures the fact that their entire performance is based on home victories with little to show abroad. In fact, India had beaten Australia at home several times in the past without such claims being made.

England is a difficult team to evaluate because their team has been in such a flux after the high point of the 2005 Ashes. The recent events surrounding Pietersen make the ratings even more irrelevant. The big underperformer is Sri Lanka, with matchwinners in Jayawardene, Sangakkara, and Murali, they have not been able to achieve better results. However, they are in striking distance of the third spot and perhaps, this may be a breakout year for them.

 

Overall Series Average for Test Playing Teams

Overall Series Average for Test Playing Teams

 

 

 

 

             Wins   Draws  Losses    Success %
Australia      11       0       3       78.57%
South Africa    9       2       3       71.43%
India           7       2       5       57.14%
England         7       1       6       53.57%
Pakistan        6       2       6       50.00%
Sri Lanka       4       5       5       46.43%
New Zealand     2       5       7       32.14%
West Indies     0       3      11       10.71%